Top 10 Women's Loafers

Refine Your Look With A Pair Of Top-Rated Loafers

Refine Your Look With A Pair Of Top-Rated Loafers

Summer may be all about sandals and winter all about boots, but that doesn't mean we can't switch things up every once in a while. As springtime approaches and we continue to tire of our go-to winter shoes, we're taking a break from boots by slipping into a true classic: loafers. Not only are they perfect for this transitional period where things are starting to warm up but we'd still like a little coverage, but they're also polished enough for work, comfortable enough for walking, and versatile enough to pair with pretty much everything. We could sing the praises of this put-together shoe for ages, but we'll go ahead and get to the good part. Below, we're bringing you a science-backed list of the most popular loafers on the internet—all of which were ranked and approved by our data-driven algorithm that factors in real user reviews, best-selling buzz, editorial mentions, and more. From iconic designer options to Meghan Markle's faves to finds you won't believe ring up under $100, keep scrolling to discover and shop the Top 10 loafers you can buy. Opening image: @birdies

Did you like our 10 Best Women's Loafers? Check out our 10 Best White Sneakers and our 10 Best Comfortable Work Heels for more top-ranked finds!

FacebookEmail icon
February 5, 2020

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings

J.Crew Ryan Penny Loafersjcrew.com

J.Crew Ryan Penny Loafers

Our Score

WHY YOU NEED IT: As with most of J.Crew's shoes, this style is incredibly high-quality for the price. Made with beautiful, buttery-soft leather, they're comfortable right out of the box and don't need breaking in. Trust us—these will remain in your wardrobe for seasons to come.

USERS SAID: "Got these in the mail, tried them on, and couldn’t believe how comfortable they were. I put them on the next day, walked to work, and wore them all day without one issue. They have smooth leather and a great fit, and there's no need to break them in. I may just have to buy another color!"

M.Gemi The Felize

Our Score

LOVED FOR: These have been waitlisted over 36,000 times, and it's not hard to see why. Handmade in a tiny Tuscany workshop, each shoe is beautifully crafted down to every last day—including taking a flame to the edges to singe away any loose threads.

WHY WE LOVE IT: "These are the most comfortable flats I have ever worn—no break-in period necessary. The suede is so soft, they instantly mold to your foot. These might be my new go-to travel shoes."—Beth Zerdecki, Chief Product Officer

Sperry Seaport Penny Loafer

Our Score

BEST FOR: If you're looking for something comfortable, these classic penny loafers can't be beaten. With a memory-foam footbed and EVA sole to cushion every step, they're the kind of shoes you can wear all day long without wanting to kick them off.

FUN FACT: The rubber outsole has recently been updated with Sperry Wave-Siping for superior traction, so they won't have you slipping and sliding in wet weather.

Everlane The Boss Flat

Our Score

LOVED FOR: Complete with a modern, minimal silhouette and sleek pointed toe, these beauties add a sharp touch to whatever you pair them with. Let's just say they're appropriately named.

HELPFUL TIP: According to reviews, these run a full size small—you'll want to size up for the most comfortable fit.

Everlane The Day Loafer

Our Score

WHAT IT DOES: Sharp like a loafer but easy like a slip-on, these gems from Everlane are the best of both worlds. They're sleek but incredibly comfortable.

USERS SAID: "These shoes fit me perfectly, the color is beautiful, and they go with any outfit. I recommend sizing up so that they're not too tight on the foot, but if you want a snug fit, pick your true size. The perfect shoe for any occasion!"

Gucci Brixton Convertible Loafer

Our Score

WHAT IT DOES: One of Gucci's iconic loafer designs, the Brixton is basically like getting two pairs of luxury shoes for the price of one. You can wear them as classic loafers or fold the flexible heel and sport them as breezy mules.

WHY YOU NEED IT: Well, besides the whole two-shoes-in-one thing, the leather on Gucci's loafers is known to age like fine wine. These are a closet staple and will be for years—no doubt about it.

Madewell The Elinor Loafer

Our Score

LOVED FOR: Now updated with an extra layer of padding in the sole, these classic loafers are crazy comfortable. You'll want to wear these all day long, from your morning commute to post-work happy-hour functions.

USERS SAID: "This shoe is it. It's dressed up and casual and edgy and classic all at the same time, with a little bit of heel. I commute several miles per day, so I have to have comfortable shoes that are truly made for walking. These do that job, too."

Sam Edelman Loraine Loafer

Our Score

WHY YOU NEED IT: We don't know about you, but we would totally mistake these for a designer find if we didn't know any better. $120? Thank you, Sam Edelman.

HELPFUL TIP: Some say these loafers run narrow, so if your feet are on the wider side, you may need to size up.

Birdies The Starling Loafer

Our Score

BEST FOR: If you're going for a slipper vibe, the Starling Loafer is for you. With rich velvet and a range of gorgeous shades, they add instant elegance to every outfit you pair them with.

AS SEEN ON: We're not surprised that Meghan Markle is a big fan of Birdies.

Sam Edelman Lior Loafer

Our Score

LOVED FOR: Upgraded with of-the-moment details like gleaming horse-bit hardware and even a python-print option, these loafers are a little edgier than most.

STYLE WITH: This style is seriously versatile. Wear these with a blazer for the office, then swap it for a cool-girl moto jacket for the weekend.

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.