Our Top 10 Lists help shoppers quickly and easily find what they need. Using an intense review and approval process (which you can learn more about here), we break down the best products according to what consumers most commonly search for and want.
Eyeliner is one of the most versatile makeup products on the market. Whether you want a no-makeup-makeup look or full-on glam, the right one can help you get there. Thanks to an ever-growing amount of formulations and consistencies, there are endless possibilities when it comes to eyeliner. There are pencil liners—the most forgiving type and almost exclusively reserved for the upper eyelid and waterline. Liquid liners deliver bold, intense shapes and precise lines, and gel liners provide a mix of precision and intense pigment.
No matter what variation of eyeliner you prefer, the formula should be long-lasting and—most importantly—right for your eyes. Ahead, we're giving you the lowdown on the 10 best eyeliners for every eye shape, makeup look, and skill level so you can find your new go-to.
Our Method For Finding The Best Eyeliners
Finding the perfect eyeliner is no easy task. Lucky for you, we’ve used our unique algorithm that factors in best-seller lists, user reviews, and editor picks to round up a list of the 10 best eyeliners on the market. With pencil, gel, and liquid options to choose from in countless shades and finishes, you’re sure to find the perfect one for your routine. Keep scrolling to shop the best eyeliners you can buy.
Next up, check out the 10 Best Eyeshadow Sticks. Opening image: @covergirl
Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.
The Rankings
.png&w=3840&q=75)
NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eye Liner Pencil
RETRACTABLE
LOVED FOR: Though it's incredibly creamy and hydrating, this retractable eyeliner offers smudge-proof wear and color payoff that lasts for hours.
WHO IT'S FOR: This eyeliner is heat and humidity-resistant, making it the perfect pick for those looking for something summer-proof.
More Colors
.png&w=3840&q=75)
KVD Beauty Tattoo Liner
BEGINNER-FRIENDLY
WHY YOU NEED IT: Designed to deliver precise application even for those new to liquid liner, this pick has a cult-like following for its serious pigment, easy-to-use shape, and cruelty-free formula.
FUN FACT: This eyeliner is an Allure Best of Beauty Award winner.
More Colors
Cruelty Free
.png&w=3840&q=75)
Lancôme Artliner Precision Point Eyeliner
BEST FOR CAT EYES
WHAT IT DOES: Thanks to the uniquely shaped foam tip, Artliner allows you to create the coolest eye looks with ease. Plus, the fool-proof formula doesn't dry immediately, so you've got time to fix any mistakes.
THINGS TO KNOW: Formulated to deliver long-lasting, all-day wear, this liner is made with a combo of film-forming polymers that prevent smudging.
More Colors
Tom Ford Eye Defining Liquid Liner Pen
SPLURGE-WORTHY
WHY YOU NEED IT: Dual-ended packaging ensures you get the best of both worlds with this liquid liner pen. It boasts a fine calligraphy tip for expert-level precision and a brush side for smokier looks.
USER REVIEW: "I don't usually write reviews, but I wanted to for anyone who's on the fence about purchasing this product. Let me just say, this liquid liner blows all the others out of the water. This is HANDS DOWN the best liquid liner I've ever used. The brush enables you to make the most precise and sharp line as thin or thick as you want. Making a cat eye has never been easier with this product. While it's expensive, it is totally worth it."
CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
BEST FOR SMOKEY EYES
WHAT IT DOES: Achieving the perfect smokey eye has never been easier. This versatile pen comes with a soft tip that smudges eyeliner to deliver dramatic, bold looks in a cinch.
THINGS TO KNOW: Thanks to the self-sharpening tip, you'll never have to worry about this eyeliner going dull.
.png&w=3840&q=75)
Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner
WATERPROOF
WHY YOU NEED IT: Available in a wide range of color options, this waterproof liner comes in both shimmer and matte finishes and boasts a creamy consistency that blends like a dream.
HELPFUL TIP: Reviewers say this formula is excellent for lining the waterline.
More Colors
Maybelline Curvitude Liner
LASH-ENHANCING
WHAT IT DOES: Designed with an intentional curve, this eyeliner applies product along the eye contour to fill in between the lash line and deliver fuller-looking lashes.
WHO IT'S FOR: According to reviews, the shape of this eyeliner makes it perfect for hooded eyes.
.png&w=3840&q=75)
Ilia Clean Line Gel Liner
GEL
LOVED FOR: This squeaky-clean formula delivers an effortless glide and easy blend-ability. Plus, it boasts excellent color payoff and is water-resistant.
USER REVIEW: "I love this eyeliner! It glides on smoothly and stays put, but it's still easy to correct any mistakes. And the ingredients are something I feel good about. I won’t buy another brand! I’ve reordered multiple times."
More Colors
Cruelty Free
.png&w=3840&q=75)
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil
PENCIL
WHY YOU NEED IT: With its creamy texture, this liner smudges like a kohl pencil—a quality that's tough to find in waterproof formulas. It's perfect for creating the boldest smokey eye looks.
LOVED FOR: No rom-com, muggy day, or hot yoga sesh is enough to make this stuff budge. It stays put all day but washes away easily with a good cleanser.
More Colors
Cruelty Free
.png&w=3840&q=75)
Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
BEST OVERALL
WHAT IT DOES: Formulated to last through whatever challenges your day brings, this liquid liner applies smoothly and works well for dramatic looks and subtle ones alike.
USER REVIEW: “This is my favorite product on earth! I have bought this countless times, and although I have tried other liquid eyeliners, this is my favorite one. I always end up going back to it. It's my holy-grail liner!”
More Colors
Cruelty Free
