Top 10 Cream Eyeshadows

The Best Cream Eyeshadows That Won't Crease Or Budge

The Best Cream Eyeshadows That Won't Crease Or Budge

Our Top 10 Lists help shoppers quickly and easily find what they need. Using an intense review and approval process (which you can learn more about here), we break down the best styles according to what consumers most commonly search for and want.

At Rank and Style, we love a good five-minute makeup look. We understand that sometimes you may not have more than an hour to get ready, and there may be days when you prefer a no-makeup-makeup look or an effortless, minimalist vibe. This is one of the main reasons we love cream eyeshadows.

You might be more familiar with powder eyeshadows since they’re one of the pioneering formulas, but makeup has evolved since then, and bright minds have created cream eyeshadows for the benefit of saving time. Perfect for the no-fuss kind of girl, cream eyeshadows are perfect for an uncomplicated eye look since they're so easy to apply—you can just dab and blend the product onto your eyelids and add different shades to create dimension and a beautiful, layered look. If you’re not skilled at makeup, cream eyeshadows could be your next best friend. They’re also great for adding a pop of color to a natural base, or for adding glitter onto your eyelid if you’re going for a glam look. Because they're cream-based, they’re relatively long-lasting and can look a lot more natural on your skin. And when you're on the go or simply need a touch-up, they'll be really handy.

How We Found The Best Cream Eyeshadows

The eye shadow section in any beauty or drugstore can be overwhelming, especially if you’re not really into makeup. To make it easier, we tapped our unique algorithm and rounded up a list of the 10 best cream eyeshadows on the market. This proprietary tool factors in best-selling buzz, editor recommendations, rave reviews, and more to find the best products on the web, which is why you can feel confident that you're only seeing the products that are really worth buying. Ahead, shop the best cream eyeshadows on the shelves, from drugstore finds to luxury buys.

Next up, check out the 10 Best Contour Sticks. Opening image: @BobbiBrown

FacebookEmail icon
September 7, 2021

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings

Tom Ford Cream Color For Eyessephora.com

Tom Ford Cream Color For Eyes

Our Score


WHO IT'S FOR: If you’re looking for a cream eyeshadow that will give you a subtle yet glowy look, this is the one for you. With its metallic colors, you'll flaunt a soft, shimmering glow and look very well-rested.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: This is an excellent choice if you want to elevate your no-makeup-makeup look.

Maybelline New York Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal 24HR Cream Gel Eyeshadow

Our Score


WHY IT MADE THE LIST: This product boasts an intense color payoff at an affordable price. Don it when you want to add a fun pop of color to your eyelids.

HELPFUL TIP: Though creamy and smooth, you may want to dab a bit of water on it before applying it onto your lids as this product tends to dry.

Hourglass Scattered Light Glitter Eye Shadow

Our Score


WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: With micro-glitters and light-reflecting pearls, this cult-favorite shadow effortlessly draws attention to the eyes. It's a perfect add-on to a smoky eye and works great as a neutral base for a chic look.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: This shadow is buildable, and it will stay on all day—even if you have oily lids. 

MAC Cosmetics Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eyeshadow

Our Score


WHAT IT DOES: A cult-favorite, MAC's Pro Longwear Paint Pots can be used as an eyeshadow base, an eyelid primer, or just to even out the color on your eyelids.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: This line provides you with four shimmery cream eyeshadows and 11 matte cream eyeshadows that are great on older skin, too.

Charlotte Tilbury Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow

Our Score


WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Known for its serious longevity and ease of blending, this eyeshadow is luxurious and super creamy—perfect if you plan on taking your look from day to night.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: A little product goes a long way. It blends like a dream and won’t crease, even if you have hooded eyelids.

Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Our Score


WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Glitter on your face can be daunting, but this product lasts all day while being easy to remove.

HELPFUL TIP: Glide this glitter liquid eyeshadow on the inner corners of your eyes for that subtle pop, or use it all over your eyelids for an intense sparkle.

Revlon ColorStay Creme Eyeshadow

Our Score


WHY IT MADE THE LIST: Pair this cream eyeshadow with your waterproof mascara of choice, and your makeup will never budge. It's best used on a hot summer day when you’re prone to sweating.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: The color range of these cream eyeshadows leans toward cool tones. They come with built-in brushes, too

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Eyeshadow Stick

Our Score


WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: This space-saving eyeshadow stick will glide on your eyelids beautifully. Plus, it's available in both matte and shimmer finishes that work together to create a complete makeup look that's ready to go wherever you go.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: These are vegan, paraben-free, sulfate-free, and waterproof.

Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème To Powder Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick

Our Score


WHY IT MADE THE LIST: Glide and go with the help of these cream-to-powder shimmer sticks. Once the product sets, it gives off a velvety finish. Your everyday makeup bag needs this.

HELPFUL TIP: You don’t need a primer for this since it has a powder finish, though you might want to work quickly with this one. We recommend doing one eye first, then waiting for it to dry before starting on the other eye.

Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Shadow

Our Score


WHY IT MADE THE LIST: This versatile, long-lasting eyeshadow can also be used for highlighting, lining, and creating smoky looks. It’s a great tool if you like to change up your look on the regular.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: These will slide seamlessly onto your lids and last all day, even without primer.

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.