When it comes to putting on makeup, what you do with your eyebrows can make or break an entire look. If you get a little too passionate about tweezing, you’ll be left with little to no hairs to work with. Should you press down too hard with an eyebrow pencil, it may look as though you used a Sharpie marker instead. Forget to apply your setting gel and that perfectly feathered arch will disappear before lunchtime. It's safe to say the stakes are high when it comes to the space above the eyes. Hit every mark but something still seems to be off? If that’s the case, it may be time for you to get acquainted with brow bone highlighter.
It's a niche item for sure, but adding some shine to the area just below the tail end of each brow can provide the type of dimension and glowy payoff achieved by your favorite makeup artists. What makes brow bone highlighters even more appealing is that, like many other makeup products, they can be applied elsewhere on the face, such as along the waterlines and on the eyelids. Brow bone highlighters also come packaged in a variety of ways—jumbo pencils, pomades, and powders, to name a few. When shopping for a brow bone highlighter, aim for a shade that complements your skin tone and a finish that won’t clash with your personal makeup style. Your product of choice should also be easy to blend, whether you’re using an applicator or your fingers.
How We Found The Best Brow Bone Highlighters
If you’re new to brow bone highlighter and unsure where to begin your search, we’ve got you covered with a diverse list of products and price points. As always, we consulted our unbiased and ultra-smart algorithm for help. This proprietary tool selects products based on a spectrum of trustworthy data, including social media buzz, expert recommendations, and product reviews. Discover your new secret brow weapon below.
Next up, check out the 10 Best Brow Products. Opening image: sephora.com
Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.
Benefit Cosmetics High Brow Dual Ended Highlighting Eyebrow Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: If you want the option of going back and forth between a matte or shimmery highlight, try Benefit’s dual-ended eyebrow pencil, which comes in three color combos to suit different skin tones.
APPLICATION TIP: For the highest level of brow definition, apply the matte formula as your base and top it with the shimmery one.
Kylie Cosmetics Kybrow Highlighter
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Kylie Jenner’s “Kybrow” has a silky-smooth formula that blends beautifully into the skin without leaving behind any creases—even after hours of wear.
APPLICATION TIP: Apply just a small amount of pressure to avoid overdoing it with the jumbo pencil applicator.
Made In Usa
Morphe Highlighter Stick
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Morphe’s travel-friendly highlighter stick comes in four universally flattering shades that are ultra-blendable.
APPLICATION TIP: You can use this highlighter stick on your eyelids as well—it makes for a perfect eyeshadow base.
Clinique Instant Lift for Brows
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Clinique’s double-ended Instant Lift For Brows is a must-have for busybodies and small storage spaces. One end is a brow pencil and the other a highlighter stick: the ultimate twofer.
APPLICATION TIP: Blend out the brow highlighter toward the temples.
Kelley Baker Brows Camo-Light Highlighter Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: This commuter-friendly pencil is renowned for its ability to cover up rogue hairs between brow appointments, and of course, its ability to create the illusion of lifted brows.
APPLICATION TIP: Take advantage of the pencil point and create a guideline for filling in your brows.
NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: If you’re wild about color, you’ll go bananas for the selection of shades available for this all-in-one pencil that can be used as a brow highlighter, eyeshadow, and eyeliner.
APPLICATION TIP: Start with eyeliner during the day and blend it out for a transition into the night.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Pro Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: If you’re more of a no-makeup-makeup type, Anastasia Beverly Hill’s matte pencil provides a subtle highlight to the brow or cheeks.
APPLICATION TIP: This multitasker can also be used as a lip liner, concealer, and eyeshadow base.
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: You can thank Thrive Causemetics’ exclusive Ring Light Technology for the radiant, diffused glow that this brightening pencil gives off, no matter the shade.
APPLICATION TIP: This one is ophthalmologist- and dermatologist-approved, so don’t be afraid to apply more than one layer if desired.
Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil: Eye, Lip & Brow Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Make Up For Ever’s Artist Color Pencil is truly one-of-a-kind. In addition to its versatility—you can use it on the lips, brows, and face—it also comes in over 30 bold shades with runway-worthy color payoff.
APPLICATION TIP: Combine this with the brand’s Step 1 Eye & Lip Primer if you want longer wear.
Anastasia Beverly Hills Highlighting Duo Pencil
WHY PEOPLE LOVE IT: Anastasia Beverly Hills is the gold standard for brow products, so it should come as no surprise that their Highlighting Duo Pencil is at the top of this list. The dual-ended pencil—with one side matte and one side shimmer—is infused with Vitamin E for that second-skin finish (and added moisture).
APPLICATION TIP: Make the matte your daytime staple and break out the shimmer before a night out on the town.