10.
Arch Support
09.
Comfort
08.
Suede
07.
Italian-Made
06.
Iconic
05.
Block-Heeled
04.
Maximum Height
03.
Affordable
02.
Designer
01.
Best Overall


Womens/Shoes/Heels/Evening & Work
Top 10 Basic Black Pumps

Your Definitive Shopping Guide To The Internet's Best Black Pumps

Your Definitive Shopping Guide To The Internet's Best Black Pumps

What can we say about black heels that hasn’t been said before? They’re undeniably classic, iconic, and versatile, which is why they’ve earned the title of closet staple along with little black dresses and a good pair of blue jeans.

Even more impressive, black pumps are both work-appropriate and party-ready. They look just as great with your favorite work dress as they do with denim and a stylish top, and if you find the right pair, you might be able to stroll out of the office and on with your night without needing to ice your feet or switch into your emergency flats.

Speaking of picking the right pair, we know how difficult it can be to find quality, comfortable heels, especially if you’re shopping online and can’t give them a spin in the store. However, we’ve rounded up a list of the best reviewer-approved black pumps out there, from an affordable Banana Republic pair to some iconic Jimmy Choos.

How We Found The Best Classic Black Pumps

Gone are the days of returns and buyer’s remorse, because our data-driven approach to finding and ranking the best products out there factors in best-seller lists, user reviews, and editorial mentions—so you can trust that you’re getting unbiased, science-backed recommendations. Start making room in your closet, because odds are you’ll fall in love with at least one of the 10 pairs of heels that made this list.

Next up, check out 10 Best Nude Pumps For Every Skin ToneOpening image: shopbop.com

FacebookEmail icon
December 21, 2021

Top 10 Lists serve as unbiased shopping guides to the most trusted product recommendations on the internet. Products are scored and ranked using an algorithm backed by data consumers find most valuable when making a purchase. We are reader-supported and may earn a commission when you shop through our links.

The Rankings


10
Naturalizer Anna Pointed Toe Pumpdillards.com

Naturalizer Anna Pointed Toe Pump

Arch Support
Our Score4.25

WHY YOU NEED THEM: Both elegant and flirty, these pumps have a low topline that dips along the sides of your feet to show just a 

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Not only do reviewers say these heels are the perfect height, but they also mention that they can wear them for hours at a time without any foot pain. Count us in.

More Colors


Banana Republic Madison 12-Hour Pump

Comfort
Our Score4.45

WHY YOU NEED THEM: Is there a more classic-looking pair of heels than these? Probably not. Plus, they're made for hours of wear with flexible leather, an insole designed for comfort, and skid-resistant outsoles.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Reviewers praise these pumps for how comfortable they are, with one buyer even going so far as to say putting them on feels like wearing a pair of slippers.

More Colors


J.Crew Elsie Suede Pumps

Suede
Our Score4.55

WHY YOU NEED THEM: You need a pair of suede heels in your repertoire, and these are the real deal—they’re even made in Italy, the shoemaking capital of the world.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: According to reviewers, these heels will complement every outfit in your closet. They also love the forgiving width of the pointed toe and the padding on the ball of the foot.


M.Gemi The Esatto 90mm

Italian-Made
Our Score4.55

WHY YOU NEED THEM: It doesn’t matter if you’re a patent leather person or a suede enthusiast, because these heels are available in three kinds of black leather. Plus, they’re designed to evenly distribute weight, so you can walk confidently and wobble-free.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Many of the reviewers mention owning these shoes in several different colors, which is a testament to their quality and versatility. They also describe the leather as soft and supple.

More Colors

Eco friendly

Eco Friendly


Jimmy Choo Romy 100 Pointed-Toe Pumps

Iconic
Our Score4.6

WHY YOU NEED THEM: If you’re going to shell out for a pair of designer black pumps, Jimmy Choos are the way to go—

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: The leather material has been described as “soft like butter,” and despite the relatively simple design, reviewers say these pumps have a very sexy vibe.

More Colors


Marc Fisher LTD. Zala Pump

Block-Heeled
Our Score4.65

WHY YOU NEED THEM: If you’ve been scrolling through this list waiting for a pair of block heels, they’re finally here, and they won’t disappoint you. Complete with a pointed toe, these are perfect for work but still stylish enough to wear to a wedding.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Any time a pair of heels is described as “easy to walk in,” an angel gets its wings. Let’s just say these heels are responsible for a handful of angels flying high.

More Colors


Sarah Flint Perfect Pump 100

Maximum Height
Our Score4.65

WHY YOU NEED THEM: Naming a shoe the “Perfect Pump” is a bold move, but these heels have over 100 five-star reviews to back them up. Plus, they were designed with customer feedback in mind, so you know you’re stepping into a well-crafted pair of pumps.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: The wide toe box, extra sole padding, and steel stiletto rod all come together to create a truly comfortable pair of heels.

More Colors


Michael Michael Kors Dorothy Flex Leather Pointed Toe High-Heel Pumps

Affordable
Our Score4.7

WHY YOU NEED THEM: At just over three inches high, this pair of heels is one of the shortest options on our list. We also love the stud detail on the back that acts as a subtle nod to Michael Kors’s flashiness.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Several reviewers use the words “rich” and “expensive” to describe how these look, so if you’re in the market for a pair of pumps that convey luxury, these might be the ones for you.

More Colors


Christian Louboutin Pigalle Follies Pointed Toe Pump

Designer
Our Score4.8

WHY YOU NEED THEM: We’re all well aware of the impact red bottoms have had on fashion culture. So, whenever you’re in the mood to splurge on a pair of pumps, these Louboutins will be waiting with their slimmed-down stiletto heel and shiny patent leather finish.

ADDITIONAL THINGS TO KNOW: According to Nordstrom, these heels run small. They recommend ordering a half size up from your usual fit.

More Colors


Sam Edelman Hazel Pointy Toe Pump

Best Overall
Our Score4.95

WHY YOU NEED THEM: The seam on the arch of the foot and the charm on the back makes these pumps anything but basic. They’re also one of the more affordable options on this list, so if you love them, why not order a second pair in that fun pink confetti color?

WHY PEOPLE LOVE THEM: Versatility is a strong suit for these heels. One reviewer said it perfectly: “Great with dresses, fun with jeans.” 

More Colors

Straight-to-the-point emails to make finding what you love even easier.